D
danyluis
New Member
Venezuela
Venezuelan spanish
- May 31, 2009
- #1
Hello, everybody:
If I have a device that I use to collect information, should I write:
1 - This device is suitable to collect information
or
2 - This device is suitable for collecting information
?
Thanks in advance,
Dany.
cuchuflete
Senior Member
Maine, EEUU
EEUU-inglés
- May 31, 2009
- #2
Hello danyluis,
In AE (American English), the second is idiomatic. The first sounds unnatural.
D
danyluis
New Member
Venezuela
Venezuelan spanish
- May 31, 2009
- #3
Thank you very much.
-Dany
brian
Senior Member
- May 31, 2009
- #4
Agreed. The only time (I can think of) where "to" and "for" may be interchangeable is when it deals with a person:
This computer is suitable to you.
This computer is suitable for you.
I think I'd still prefer for here, but bear in mind that:
1) to sounds much better here than the to in your sentence above, and
2) for (and to here) has a very different meaning from the for (and to) used in your sentence above.
I hope that wasn't confusing. I think maybe it was. :-/
R
Rational_gaze
Senior Member
British English
- May 31, 2009
- #5
Isn't it simply 'suited to' and 'suitable for'?
"This device is suited to the collection of information"
"This device is suitable for collecting information" (as originally posted - it doesn't sound unnatural to me).
ouzhantekin
Senior Member
Izmir/ 伊兹密尔
Turkish - Standard
- Jul 18, 2012
- #6
It's like reviving a very old topic (app. 3 years old ) but I had to say that I've seen these sample sentences in Oxford Dictionary of Collocations, which, to me, sounds like a reliable source :
suitable:
The walk is suitable for all family. (As you guys already agreed)
...conditions suitable
their development . (??)
and also taking the last reply into consideration:
He wasn't really suited
for army life. (??)
...an approach easily suited to adult learners. (as it is already been pointed out)
I hope I can get a reply otherwise I will feel forced to open a new topic for this
D
danyluis
New Member
Venezuela
Venezuelan spanish
- Jul 18, 2012
- #7
Thank you, ouzhantekin. Certainly, this is an old topic, but useful answers are always welcomed.
-Dany
A
AM3F77
New Member
Arabic
- Nov 27, 2012
- #8
"it's" Suitable for "person"
"it's" Suitable to "it"
"Person" is/are Suitable for "it" or "person"
can we consider that as acorrect roles??
wandle
Senior Member
London
English - British
- Nov 27, 2012
- #9
'Suited' expresses a specific judgement and the more direct pronoun 'to' is therefore appropriate.
'He was not well suited to such a life.'
'Suitable' is a more general judgement and the less definite pronoun 'for' is appropriate in this case.
'That heavy pot is not suitable for stir-fry cooking.'
A point to remember is that 'suited' is often used to express a judgement about a person, while 'suitable' often refers to something we use.
A
AM3F77
New Member
Arabic
- Nov 28, 2012
- #10
I appreciate your reply, thanks?
L
loverofenglish
Senior Member
Vietnam
Vietnamese
- Jul 17, 2013
- #11
What is the difference between "suited (to somebody/something)" and "suited (for somebody/something)", please?
suited (to somebody/something)
-She was ideally suited to the part of Eva Peron.
-This diet is suited to anyone who wants to lose weight fast.
-This was a job to which he seemed well suited.
suited (for somebody/something)
-He is not really suited for a teaching career.
http://oald8.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/dictionary/suited
L
lingkky
Senior Member
chinese
- Jun 19, 2017
- #12
danyluis said:
Hello, everybody:
If I have a device that I use to collect information, should I write:
1 - This device is suitable to collect information
or
2 - This device is suitable for collecting information
?Thanks in advance,
Dany.
May I know what is the difference in meaning between the both sentences?
Ali Smith
Banned
Urdu - Pakistan
- Feb 19, 2021
- #13
"I would love to have a meeting with you to discuss this project in greater detail or a different project you think would be suitable to a person of my background."
Would "for a person of my background" be more idiomatic?
M
mj99
Banned
English - United States
- Feb 19, 2021
- #14
danyluis said:
Hello, everybody:
If I have a device that I use to collect information, should I write:
1 - This device is suitable to collect information
or
2 - This device is suitable for collecting information
?Thanks in advance,
Dany.
I think both are correct here.
You must log in or register to reply here.